Small Holiday Goodie Box
$35
24 pieces — 4 each of 6 homemade favorites
- Decorated sugar cookies
- Peanut butter blossoms
- Snowball cookies
- Chocolate crinkle cookies
- Chocolate fudge
- Rice crispy bars
The Siouxville Goodie Shoppe
Holiday Goodie Box • Baked with Mischief
Pre-orders are open! Homemade holiday goodie boxes, baked with love right here in Sioux Falls. Every box arrives gift-ready in decorative packaging — no wrapping needed. Each treat is tucked in its own little bag, so everything stays fresher, longer.
Pre-Orders Close Soon!
Loading countdown…
Pre-orders close Tuesday, December 1, 2026. When a box sells out, it is gone.
Please note: pre-orders MUST be paid upon order. Place your order below and pay right away with Venmo, Cash App, Zelle, or PayPal, and your order is in!
NO ORDERS ARE COMPLETE UNTIL PAYMENT IS RECEIVED.
Large Holiday Goodie Box
$60
48 pieces — 4 each of 12 homemade favorites
- Decorated sugar cookies
- Peanut butter blossoms
- Snowball cookies
- Chocolate crinkle cookies
- Chocolate fudge
- Rice crispy bars
- Gingerbread cookies
- Cranberry-pistachio shortbread
- Peppermint bark
- Chocolate truffles
- Lemon bars
- Coconut macaroons
Sugar-Free & Gluten-Free Box
$50
24 pieces — 4 each of 6 sugar-free favorites
- Sugar-free peanut butter cookies
- Sugar-free chocolate chip cookies
- Sugar-free peppermint bark
- Sugar-free chocolate truffles
- Peanut butter protein bars
- Almond joy protein bars
Made with erythritol, monk fruit, stevia, and allulose — no maltitol or sorbitol. Gluten-free friendly, baked in a kitchen that also handles wheat.
À La Carte
Extra treats by the pan, loaf, dozen, or gallon bag — add them to your pre-order below.
- Fudge, 8x8 pan — $25 ($30 with nuts)
- Sugar-free fudge, 8x8 pan — $30 ($35 with nuts)
- Puppy chow, gallon zip-lock bag — $20
- Bing bars, 8x8 pan — $30
- Lemon bars, 8x8 pan — $25
- Sugar-free lemon bars, 8x8 pan — $30
- Chocolate truffles — $15 per dozen
- Sugar-free buckeyes, per dozen — $20
- Sugar-free brownies, 8x8 pan — $30
- Banana bread loaf — $12 ($15 with walnuts)
- Pumpkin bread loaf — $12
- Chocolate pretzels, gallon zip-lock bag — $10
Place Your Pre-Order
Fill this out to place your order. When you tap Place My Order, pay first with one of the payment options below, then send your paid order to Tammy by email. NO ORDERS ARE COMPLETE UNTIL PAYMENT IS RECEIVED.
Pay When You Order
Pre-orders MUST be paid upon order. Send the exact total from your order, with the note "Goodie Shoppe pre-order — your name".
NO ORDERS ARE COMPLETE UNTIL PAYMENT IS RECEIVED. After you pay, send your paid order by email using the button in the order form — it will have PAID ORDER in the subject line.
All sales are final. No refunds or exchanges.
Pay with Venmo — @MrsMonster2000 Pay with Cash App — $tdalcourt Pay with Card via PayPal
Zelle: send to 712-666-0040.
If there are any issues, please get in touch with Tammy and we can figure it out — text 605-705-0954.
Important Dates
- Pre-orders close Tuesday, December 1, 2026.
- Box caps: 25 large boxes, 40 small boxes, and 20 sugar-free boxes — when they are gone, pre-orders close early.
- Sioux City orders: brought to town Tuesday, December 22, 2026 — meetup times will be arranged around Grinch gigs and confirmed when you order. Sioux City meetup is weather permitting — if weather forces a postponement, Tammy will come another day before Christmas.
- Local pickup: Wednesday, December 23, 2026, in Sioux Falls.
Please mention any nut allergies when you order — several treats contain peanuts or tree nuts (peanut butter blossoms, snowballs with pecans, cranberry-pistachio shortbread, coconut macaroons, fudge with nuts, peanut butter protein bars, almond joy protein bars, Bing bars, puppy chow, chocolate pretzels may vary).